Author Topic: XMPlay Delix plugin (Read 252323 times)

Mindtrip · « **Reply #125 on:** 13 May '07 - 12:19 »

I've installed a clean XMPlay v3.4.1 and extracted xmp-delix.zip into the same folder, but I get the following error message as well:

---------------------------
XMP-Delix plugin
---------------------------
Sorry guys...
Can't find xmp-delix.dat (xmp-delix.dat)
---------------------------
OK
---------------------------

The files are in the same folder as XMPlay.

Any ideas what I'm doing wrong?

- Mindtrip

Jokum · « **Reply #126 on:** 13 May '07 - 12:43 »

Same problem.. I have everything in the root of /xmplay .. just downloaded latest xmp-zip.dll too.. Btw. the zip plugin doesn't show up in my Plugins list under options.

But the previous Delix plugin worked fine for me.

Now I just get the error "Couldn't find xmp-delix.dat" instead. But it is there!

Fraggie · « **Reply #127 on:** 13 May '07 - 16:45 »

Ahh... I see the problem now...

It's because delix is loaded before the zip plugin in your cases. I dont know exactly in what order XMPlay loads the plugins, but it seems to be alphabetic. So, until I figure something out - if you have all plugins in the same folder, just rename xmp-delix.dll to something like xmp-zzzdelix.dll, so it get's loaded last (or at least after the zip plugin).

Or you can sort your plugins this way (as I do):
archive\xmp-zip.dll
input\xmp-delix.dll
input\xmp-delix.dat

deus-ex · « **Reply #128 on:** 13 May '07 - 17:31 »

Neither of your suggested ~funny~ solutions do work here. Let's head back into the lab, sir.

mindtrip · « **Reply #129 on:** 13 May '07 - 18:04 »

Quote from: Fraggie on 13 May '07 - 16:45

Or you can sort your plugins this way (as I do):
archive\xmp-zip.dll
input\xmp-delix.dll
input\xmp-delix.dat

Worked like a charm. And that's good enough for me.
Thanks for the solution

-Mindtrip

Jokum · « **Reply #130 on:** 13 May '07 - 20:00 »

Thanks, works.

OSH · « **Reply #131 on:** 13 May '07 - 21:38 »

Quote from: Fraggie on 13 May '07 - 10:21

This is the final Delix release.

Why Fraggie, why???

Zarggg · « **Reply #132 on:** 13 May '07 - 21:54 »

I'm guessing because there are no more features to add? That's generally why development of anything stops.

Knurek · « **Reply #133 on:** 13 May '07 - 22:19 »

Quote from: Zarggg on 13 May '07 - 21:54

I'm guessing because there are no more features to add? That's generally why development of anything stops.

There's DelixNG too.

Nukkels · « **Reply #134 on:** 13 May '07 - 23:07 »

Tried both methods, neither worked. I mean, the Delix plugin didn't work before either, so I still don't know what I'm missing...

Fraggie, there's obviously a LOT of people who are noticing some kind of incompatibility with your plugin. I don't know what it is, but I think getting it to WORK is more important than continually bringing out new beta versions. If half of the users can't use it, then spending God knows how many hours putting all that code into it is a bit of a waste of time IMHO.

Fraggie · « **Reply #135 on:** 15 May '07 - 06:48 »

Delix release 8b should have this problem fixed.
Cheers!

deus-ex · « **Reply #136 on:** 15 May '07 - 15:34 »

Quote from: Fraggie on 15 May '07 - 06:48

Delix release 8b should have this problem fixed.
Cheers!

Awesome! You're da man, again.

Xmp-Delix test v0.8b (deus-ex edition =)

Fraggie · « **Reply #137 on:** 15 May '07 - 15:46 »

Hey, now you see for yourself how hard it is to keep players.txt up to date.

deus-ex · « **Reply #138 on:** 15 May '07 - 16:25 »

Quote from: Fraggie on 15 May '07 - 15:46

Hey, now you see for yourself how hard it is to keep players.txt up to date.

Ehh, excuse me, what?

Am i missing something? No, it's not that hard at all. If you like you can readd it to your distribution as well, of course.

I noticed you didn't adress the issue with the Custom-Player module which doesn't produce any sound-output with Delix. I hope you'll look into this for Delix-NG.

Btw, i encountered a lot of SIDs having the very same problem (no sound) with your SID-plugin (Foobar2000 and Winamp plugins as well). I learned there's only one SID-player capable of playing (i.e. with soundoutput) really all and every SID: SIDplay (Windows-port) by Adam Lorentzon.

Knurek · « **Reply #139 on:** 15 May '07 - 17:40 »

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 16:25

Btw, i encountered a lot of SIDs having the very same problem (no sound) with your SID-plugin (Foobar2000 and Winamp plugins as well). I learned there's only one SID-player capable of playing (i.e. with soundoutput) really all and every SID: SIDplay (Windows-port) by Adam Lorentzon.

Uhh? You sure it's not some problem with your plugin setting? Cause I've been doing a complete HVSC listen lately and haven't found any file that wouldn't play in xmp-sid yet.

//Edit

Also that player you linked is based on libsidplay1, and as such won't actually play quite a few files from HVSC (all RSID and BASIC tunes for one).

deus-ex · « **Reply #140 on:** 15 May '07 - 18:10 »

I'm using default settings with the SID-plugin, no STIL and SLDB, emulation is set to 'sidplay2 Real C64 Environment' (default). Might any of these settings be causing the issues?

Regarding SIDPlay (Windows-port), i checked every PSID-file with this player that wouldn't play with Delix during my huge PSID update schedule at MODLAND. I only encountered one file which it wouldn't play with SIDPlay as well, so i blamed it on the file to be broken. Note though that i'm convinced you are probably more expirienced on that sector than i am.

Fraggie · « **Reply #141 on:** 15 May '07 - 19:17 »

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 16:25

Ehh, excuse me, what?
Am i missing something?

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 16:25

I noticed you didn't adress the issue with the Custom-Player module which doesn't produce any sound-output with Delix. I hope you'll look into this for Delix-NG.

There will be no new features for the Delix plugin. (Making something play almost always means adding new component to the emulation.)

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 16:25

Btw, i encountered a lot of SIDs having the very same problem (no sound) with your SID-plugin (Foobar2000 and Winamp plugins as well). I learned there's only one SID-player capable of playing (i.e. with soundoutput) really all and every SID: SIDplay (Windows-port) by Adam Lorentzon.

Prove it.

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 18:10

Regarding SIDPlay (Windows-port), i checked every PSID-file with this player that wouldn't play with Delix during my huge PSID update schedule at MODLAND.

Well, that must have been awful lot of files.

Nukkels · « **Reply #142 on:** 16 May '07 - 05:03 »

Good news is that I can now load XMPlay with the plugin installed =}

Bad news is that it still doesn't play that Star Trekker module =(

Back to the drawing board Fraggie...

piovrauz · « **Reply #143 on:** 16 May '07 - 07:56 »

I don't know if it's a bug or something I am missing, but I have some YM tunes and delix can't play them! I discovered on the support site a plugin for winamp that play these files (not wery well, tough), so I want to know if delix support this format, as in the "readme". thanks. I've got last Xmplay, last delix and last archive plugins.

Knurek · « **Reply #144 on:** 16 May '07 - 10:46 »

Quote from: piovrauz on 16 May '07 - 07:56

I don't know if it's a bug or something I am missing, but I have some YM tunes and delix can't play them! I discovered on the support site a plugin for winamp that play these files (not wery well, tough), so I want to know if delix support this format, as in the "readme". thanks. I've got last Xmplay, last delix and last archive plugins.

If you're talking about Leonard/Oxygene YM logs, then no (those are ususally LHA packed, so they should either have -lh- or YM in the begining of the file).
If you're talking about YMST files, then yes, they should be playable.

Though both formats leave much to be desired, emulation quality wise. If you're interested in Atari ST music, you should really check http://sndh.atari.org/. Unfortunately the files are only playable in WinJAM player (http://www.creamhq.de), though maybe someone will port that to Winamp/XMPlay... Well, there's also in_sc68 player, but it's somewhat clunky, so I wouldn't recommend it much.

Fraggie · « **Reply #145 on:** 16 May '07 - 13:21 »

Quote from: Nukkels on 16 May '07 - 05:03

Good news is that I can now load XMPlay with the plugin installed =}

Bad news is that it still doesn't play that Star Trekker module =(

Back to the drawing board Fraggie...

Not quite. Problem with your file is fairly complicated. Delix is handling only StarTrekker and AudioSculpture modules with AM/FM synthesis instead of some samples. Now, there is no 100% proof algorithm to distinguish between normal StarTrekker modules and those AM/FM-sample StarTrekker modules. Unforunately XMPlay falsely detects this file as StarTrekker-AM/FM (also does for example DeliPlayer) and passes it to Delix. Now, AudioSculpture replayer called by Delix also falsely detects this file as StarTrekker-AM/FM and tries to load the second file with information about the synthethic sounds (with .nt or .as extension). There is no such file so it exits with error, then Delix exits with error and in the end XMPlay draws this red line over the file name. One - I can't fix XMPlay (though as far as I know, this is somewhere on Ian's TODO list). Two - I can't fix the AudioScuplture replayer (no sources available), but this wouldn't help in this case anyway (unless it could be made to support also generic StarTrekker modules).

You can find some example AudioSculputre/StarTrekker-AM/FM here:
http://www.exotica.org.uk/tunes/pages/ADSC-AudioSculpture.html
http://www.exotica.org.uk/tunes/pages/MOD-StarTrekker.html

Quote from: piovrauz on 16 May '07 - 07:56

I don't know if it's a bug or something I am missing, but I have some YM tunes and delix can't play them! I discovered on the support site a plugin for winamp that play these files (not wery well, tough), so I want to know if delix support this format, as in the "readme". thanks. I've got last Xmplay, last delix and last archive plugins.

As Knurek already explained, only YMST/MYST files are supported (no YM logs).

deus-ex · « **Reply #146 on:** 16 May '07 - 16:56 »

Quote from: Fraggie on 15 May '07 - 19:17

Well, that must have been awful lot of files.

Awful lot translates to something around 40.000 files!

Quote from: Fraggie on 15 May '07 - 19:17

Quote from: deus-ex on 15 May '07 - 16:25
Btw, i encountered a lot of SIDs having the very same problem (no sound) with your SID-plugin (Foobar2000 and Winamp plugins as well).

Prove it.

As you wish.

Knurek · « **Reply #147 on:** 16 May '07 - 17:34 »

Quote from: deus-ex on 16 May '07 - 16:56

As you wish.

All of them are bad rips. I've compared them with my HVSC dir (update 46) and there are binary differences in all the files (oh, and yes, my HVSC files play fine in XMPlay). Try something different.

deus-ex · « **Reply #148 on:** 16 May '07 - 17:59 »

Quote from: Knurek on 16 May '07 - 17:34

All of them are bad rips. I've compared them with my HVSC dir (update 46) and there are binary differences in all the files (oh, and yes, my HVSC files play fine in XMPlay). Try something different.

How can you tell these are bad ripps? Is there a method to tell if a SID is broken/bad ripped or do you compare them to HVSC? Btw, Adam Lorentzon's SIDPlay plays them all fine. So does Open Cubic Player (except the one which i reported to crash Delix)!!! Figure that, good ol' OCP.

Knurek · « **Reply #149 on:** 16 May '07 - 18:45 »

Quote from: deus-ex on 16 May '07 - 17:59

How can you tell these are bad ripps? Is there a method to tell if a SID is broken/bad ripped or do you compare them to HVSC?

Basically:

1. Get the latest HVSC (update or whole package, whichever floats yer boat)
2.

3. PROFIT!

I did compare them, there's no method for detecting them automatically (but most probably they had whacked init routine or something. Case in point they were fixed in HVSC).

Quote from: deus-ex on 16 May '07 - 17:59

Btw, Adam Lorentzon's SIDPlay plays them all fine. So does Open Cubic Player (except the one which i reported to crash Delix)!!! Figure that, good ol' OCP.

Yeah, both of those players are based on libsidplay1, which was more lenient when it came to c64 emulation (and didn't emulate the sid filters at all, didn't emulate sid samples properly and had herpes).
If you'd play those files on a real C64 they'd be most probably silent as well.

Author Topic: XMPlay Delix plugin (Read 252323 times)

Mindtrip

Jokum

Jokum